Legal structure as a design instrument

Frizz23 - Actor Process Diagram

This article deals with the evolving relationship between architecture and legislation based on our experience as architects and our work on Frizz23, one of the three projects selected for the three PxB sites surrounding the Blumengroßmarkt.

As architects operating beyond the envelope of traditional practice, we see no difference between solving a design problem, and resolving pre-structural issues like the legal fabric this article focuses on.

The attached diagram shows the different layers of interaction between the network of actors involved in Project Frizz23, and the pertinent legislation. We pursued different strategies within each layer to either make the law conform to the project, or make the project conform to the law.

1. Actively changing Legislation

Rundentisch zur Liegenschaftspolitik

Working as participants within the Initiative Stadt Neudenken we have helped structure Berlin's legislation for public land sales by means of a broad dialogue between civil society and government institutions. The processes that lie behind changing legislation are incremental and slow. The negotiations at the Rundentisch zur Liegenschaftspolitik which began in 2012 are progressing, but much is yet to be accomplished.

The land sales procedure established for the three PxB sites is a critical milestone in the process of changing Berlin's Liegenschaftspolitik. The pilot procedure evolved, was refined step by step, and culminated in an exhibition and public workshop that informed the selection of the best project for each site. As a case study it informs and inspires the ongoing work to improve Berlin's legislation governing public land sales.

Changing legislation takes longer than the design and construction phases of a building. As architects we are usually confined to working within the existing legal framework, contributing to incremental change by providing innovative examples.

2. Developing references for future Legislation

The three projects that the jury selected to buy the three sites were all based on innovative cooperative development models led by architects. State regulations specified that a requirement for an architectural competition be written into the land sale contract. We proposed a new dialogue oriented alternative, and together with all stakeholders negotiated a change in the contracts.

Qualifizierende Verfahren Workshop

This Qualifizierende Verfahren (qualifying procedure) spanned four workshops and 18 months in which the state and district urban planing departments, three invited external architects, representatives of local initiatives, and the clients and architects of the three sites criticized and encouraged the successively evolving designs. This intense dialogue provided a unique non competitive framework to assure architectural quality, and build consensus and support for the proposals. It promoted deep interaction between the stakeholders and architects as the projects evolved. The process created an environment that fostered outstanding participative design.

This Qualifizierende Verfahren precedent serves as a reference for adapting legislation to encourage dialogue oriented design as a viable, co-operative alternative to an architectural competition.

3. Expanding the envelope of existing legislation

The Qualifizierende Verfahren gave us the chance to explore the architectural potential beyond the envelope specified by the Bebauungsplan. During the workshops we were able to draw on a broad panel of experts to help negotiate exceptions that would have been difficult under normal circumstances.

Frizz23 - FAR redistribution

To realize the Frizz23 building as planned, we needed seven significant exceptions from the Bebauungsplan. The most visible of which was permission to substantially exceed height requirements so we could create the project's distinctive silhouette by redistributing the permissible floor area.

Economically driven projects do not normally seek exceptions to these laws because of the time required and the risk involved. This tends to foster to buildings defined primarily by regulations instead of expressing richer architectural priorities.

4. Designing legal structures to accommodate architectural potential

To make Frizz23 possible, we created a two tiered ownership structure.

Frizz23 - einteilig - dreiteilig - kleinteilig

The outer layer was a building co-operative consisting of three separate sites for three companies, each with its own distinct ownership structure: Forum Berufsbildung e.V. a charitable company specialized in education, Miniloft Kreuzberg GbR in which were engaged as owners in addition to our role as architects, and FrizzZwanzig GbR a building co-operative that we founded to shoulder the lions share of the project.

To include Forum Berufsbildung e.V. in the project, we needed to comply with the complex and strict legislation governing charitable organizations. We consulted several experts to help us define a structure at the intersection of tax, ownership and planning law that would make the building possible.

The architecture is an expression of this complex ownership structure – Einteilig, Dreiteilig Kleinteilig (single-, triple-, multifaceted)

5. Legislation adapting to design

The co-operative Baugruppen projects developed by architects exploring new models for architectural production have exposed cracks in existing German legislation.

Frizz23 - Designing a Contract

The courts have asked the federal government to redefine property purchase tax laws to cover the specifics of the Baugruppen model. Working with experts we established a contract for FrizzZwanzig GbR not only as the basis upon which to create a community, but also to minimize the risk involved. One major challenge in this is to design for yet unknown changes in projected legislation which will happen soon after construction is completed, and which may affect the project.

When a project steps beyond the standard models, designing the legal structures is a challenge often left to lawyers. By exploring the potential of the legal framework as a design instrument, architects can expand their radius of action, and gain more control of their work.

This post began as a proposal for the legislating architecture issue of ARCH+

Historicism is anything but harmless!

Disney Land in Downtown Dresden As an art, architecture must always reflect its Zeitgeist. Now that the construction of a partial imitation of Berlin's destroyed palace has begun, we are witnessing an aggressive attempt to establish historicized facades as the only legitimate approach to our city.

Read more ...

Together

FRIZZ23 on the cover of Bauwelt Be a part of FRIZZ23 and create your new workspace together with us in the center of Berlin.

Read more ...

Crowdfunding Buildings

Crowdfunding Buildings The wave of change brought about by the internet is now hitting the shores of real estate finance. Crowdfunding can help us make our cities more malleable, more responsive and more distinct. If regulatory bodies can find a way to unleash its potential and minimize risk of abuse, crowdfunding could give communities a real say in how their neighborhoods evolve.

Read more ...

Do we need a land reform?

Potenzialwertermittlung: Reinhardtstrasse 31 We posed this question on Bkult in November 2012. Bkult is an online discussion platform run by the Bundesstiftung Baukultur, Germany's national foundation for the built environment.

Read more ...

Do It Yourself-International Building Exhibition

Hart-Waltherr Hämer at Urban Issue in 1999 In Berlin, the planned city is being complemented by a city of initiatives, a city where urban innovation is driven by a dynamic biosphere of artists, activists and entrepreneurs. Berliners are creating their city.

Read more ...

Urban Media Cultures

Book: Urban Media Cultures Media façades are a disruptive technology that could potentially redefine how we experience cities, and how we define places. This article was just published in the book Urban Media Cultures. It explores the potential implications of media façades on future urban development.

Read more ...

Guggenheim LAB

Invalid Street The Guggenheim LAB has been providing a platform for ideas surrounding urban development in Berlin.

Read more ...

Conversations: Madeleine von Mohl

conversation: Madeleine and Britta at Betahaus We are an analogue space for all the digital bohemians who finally have a place to meet. Our role is to create community.

Read more ...

Printed!

Our first newsprint Locally Grown City's first foray into traditional media was published on Saturday May 5th in the Berliner Zeitung.

Read more ...

Stories behind projects: Edouard Francois - Matthew Griffin

Discussion Architecture is decoration with holes. This building separates the decoration from the holes

Read more ...

Productive Patenschaft

uniting small and big Organizations of different scales and means should work together to create dense and vibrant developments.

Read more ...

Tender Tender

a ferris wheel on a parking lot in Linz Five principles to help people get directly involved in urban development, for the long term benefit of the city and its citizens.

Read more ...

The Tripod System

Tripod System a Mixed Ownership Development Model that combines three different ownership forms in one building.

Read more ...

Start-Up City

Realstadt Exhibition Entrepreneurship is a fundamental component of humanity's creative and transformative drive. It shapes societies, and plays an essential role in how cities change.

Read more ...

Initiative Map

Berlin-Mitte's local initiative map As one of his last acts in office, Ephraim Gothe, Mitte's Councillor for Urban Development, has created a map of all the local initiatives in his constituency. Encouraging local citizen engagement could radically transform Berlin - this is a good first step.

Read more ...

Berlin – Gap City

airport gap Communism's seismic collapse created a fault line of physical, cultural, and economic gaps that have defined Berlin.

Read more ...

Prestructures and Practice: Expanding Architecture

The Dalton Brothers

Architecture, more than any other art form, is influenced by social, economic, technical and physical structures beyond the control of the architect. These can be called prestructures and they are the matrix within which the architect works.

Read more ...

What is a Locally Grown Project?

Berlin's Palace Disappearing

This blog examines specific examples in Berlin. It describes the nuts and bolts of projects that have interacted with urban development to create an inspiring city. It explores the intersection of culture, entrepreneurship and architecture and sets this out in a piecemeal manner, which is also how the projects themselves thrive.

Read more ...

Introduction to the Locally Grown City blog

Berlin Building Sights

This blog aims to inspire you to engage yourself with your city.

It is based on our personal experience in Berlin, and focuses on the creative work behind the projects and places that make Berlin such a fascinating city.

Read more ...

Locally Grown City

SlenderBender

We see our practice as a multifaceted field of action that revolves around the city. Our own 'doing' is a testing ground for new ways to influence the urban and social structure that makes our cities tick.

Read more ...

This blog aims to inspire you to engage yourself with your city

Legal structure as a design instrument

Architecture, unlike any other art, is inextricably tied to law. Architects have shied from exploring the creative potential of this fact, and the profession suffers as a result.

Read more ...